There is something rather unusual about Extra Geography. At first glance, Molly Manners' feature debut might seem like another coming-of-age story about teenage friendship, romantic discoveries and the complicated business of growing up. However, there is a distinctly different approach to these familiar themes, one that gives the film a personality of its own.
Set in an English girls' boarding school, the story follows best friends Flic and Minna, two academically ambitious teenagers who decide that becoming more worldly might improve their chances of getting into Oxford or Cambridge. Their solution? They need to fall in love. And, in true teenage fashion, they approach this romantic endeavour with an almost academic level of planning and determination.
Naturally, things don't quite work out as expected.
What makes Extra Geography interesting is precisely the way it approaches love and romance. Rather than presenting these feelings as something inherently magical or spontaneous, the film initially treats them as something rather distant, calculated and almost businesslike. Love becomes a project, something to investigate, pursue and eventually tick off the list of experiences required to become a more interesting person.
It's an unusual perspective, but one that works surprisingly well.
Extra Geography Offers an Unconventional Perspective on Love
One of the film's biggest strengths is how it uses this rather detached approach to explore some genuinely interesting aspects of teenage relationships. Flic and Minna don't necessarily understand what they're looking for, but they have a very clear idea of what they think they should be looking for. Their attempts to organise something as unpredictable as falling in love are amusing, but they also reveal quite a bit about their insecurities, ambitions and understanding of the world.
Meanwhile, their seemingly unbreakable friendship gradually becomes more complicated as jealousy, competition and changing romantic interests enter the picture.
It's here that Extra Geography manages to touch upon some worthwhile subjects. Friendship can be just as complicated as romance, especially when two people are growing up at different speeds and start discovering different things about themselves. The film recognises that affection, insecurity, selfishness and rivalry can comfortably coexist, particularly during those formative teenage years.
I also appreciate that the film doesn't feel the need to turn every one of these observations into a particularly heavy dramatic moment. Instead, it approaches much of its material with a light touch, allowing the humour to do quite a bit of the work.
A Distinctive Style That Keeps Things Lighthearted
Stylistically, Extra Geography is reasonably unique as well. There's a certain artificiality to its presentation, its dialogue and the way its characters approach situations, but this ultimately becomes part of the film's charm.
It doesn't necessarily strive for complete realism, nor does it constantly try to convince you that you're watching some deeply profound examination of adolescence. Instead, it embraces its own slightly peculiar identity, finding plenty of entertainment in the awkwardness, absurdity and occasionally ridiculous logic of teenage behaviour.
The result is a film that manages to address subjects such as identity, sexuality, friendship and the complexities of growing up without becoming overly serious or emotionally demanding.
That doesn't mean there's nothing meaningful underneath the surface. Quite the opposite, actually. There are some good observations here, particularly regarding the way young people try to understand and categorise feelings they haven't quite experienced before. It's just that Extra Geography prefers to approach these things with a wink rather than a particularly dramatic flourish.
And honestly, that's a perfectly enjoyable approach.
Marni Duggan and Galaxie Clear Deliver Authentic Performances
The performances are another important part of what makes the film work. Marni Duggan and Galaxie Clear, in particular, bring a certain authenticity to their respective characters. There's an unpolished quality to their performances that fits the material rather nicely, making their friendship and occasional disagreements feel reasonably believable.
That said, I'm not going to pretend that these are performances that will necessarily blow you away. The actresses are relatively inexperienced, and while they do a good enough job of carrying the film and keeping you invested in their characters, there's also a noticeable limitation to what they bring to the table.
They are convincing enough to take you along for the ride, and their interactions provide the film with much of its charm. However, don't necessarily expect to be profoundly moved or emotionally devastated by their performances, even if you happen to identify with the characters or recognise certain experiences from your own teenage years.
Alice Englert provides a welcome additional presence as Miss Delavigne, while the supporting cast helps round out the film's slightly eccentric school environment.
Ultimately, the performances are good enough for what the film wants to accomplish, even if they don't elevate the material into something particularly extraordinary.
Final Verdict: Is Extra Geography Worth Watching?
Extra Geography is a film with a genuinely distinctive approach to familiar coming-of-age themes. Its somewhat calculated and detached perspective on love is an interesting way of exploring teenage emotions, while its lighthearted presentation ensures that the material remains entertaining rather than becoming unnecessarily sentimental.
It has some worthwhile things to say about friendship, romantic expectations, jealousy and growing up, even if it doesn't always manage to translate those observations into particularly powerful emotional moments.
The inexperienced cast does a respectable job, although their performances are more functional and authentic than genuinely outstanding. Similarly, the film's unusual style and playful tone are appealing, but they don't necessarily make for an experience that will leave a particularly lasting emotional impression.
Still, there's enough personality here to make Extra Geography stand out from the crowd. It's an entertaining, occasionally insightful and rather unconventional coming-of-age comedy-drama that deserves some credit for approaching its subject matter from a slightly different angle.
Not quite the emotionally overwhelming experience it could perhaps have been, but certainly an enjoyable little film with its own identity.
Rating: 7/10
