Some movies are carried by their story, others by their visuals, and then there are movies that rely almost entirely on the strength of their cast. Confession definitely belongs in the latter category. Directed by Václav Marhoul and written by Ben Shapiro, this historical psychological drama features a surprisingly impressive collection of actors. Unfortunately, having a talented cast doesn't automatically make for an equally compelling movie.
Set in Stalin's Moscow in 1938, Confession follows Alexei (Rob Lowe), a former literature professor who is arrested and brought to the infamous Lubyanka Prison. Accused of conspiring with a dissident priest, he finds himself facing interrogation by Vladimir (James Franco), a brilliant but ruthless former student. What follows is largely a battle of words, beliefs, morality and personal convictions, as the two men confront their past and their opposing views of the world.
It's an interesting premise, and there is certainly enough material here to build a compelling psychological drama. However, while Confession has some clear strengths, it also struggles with several filmmaking issues that prevent it from reaching its full potential.
A Surprisingly Strong Cast Carries Confession
One of the biggest selling points of Confession is undoubtedly its cast. Rob Lowe, James Franco, Nick Nolte, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Emile Hirsch, Brad Dourif, Dean Norris and Richard Brake are just some of the recognisable names appearing in the film. That's quite an impressive collection of talent, especially considering the relatively modest scale of the production.
It's particularly nice to see Rob Lowe taking on such a substantial role again. He does a decent job as Alexei, providing the film with a character who has enough history and personal conflict to keep the conversations interesting. James Franco, meanwhile, makes a strong impression as Vladimir. He brings an intensity to the character that works particularly well during the interrogation scenes, making him one of the more compelling elements of the entire production.
Nick Nolte also manages to leave an impression. His performance has its moments, although it's difficult not to notice that he frequently appears to be reading his lines from something positioned just outside the frame. It's rather distracting at times, but he still manages to bring a certain presence to the screen.
The supporting cast is equally impressive on paper, with Jennifer Jason Leigh, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Emile Hirsch, Brad Dourif, Dean Norris and Richard Brake adding plenty of experience to the mix. Unfortunately, not everyone gets enough material to make a lasting impression.
Another problem is the performances of some of the extras, which are unfortunately far from convincing. There are moments when their reactions and general behaviour feel rather artificial, making it harder to fully immerse yourself in the world of the film.
Confession Suffers From Static Cinematography and Cheap Production Design
While the cast is one of the film's biggest strengths, the technical aspects are considerably less impressive. The cinematography by Peter Menzies Jr. feels just a little too static for a film like this. Given how much of Confession revolves around conversations and interrogations, some restraint in the camera work is understandable. However, there is a difference between a deliberately restrained visual approach and simply failing to give a film enough visual variety.
Unfortunately, Confession doesn't always find that balance. The camera often remains in relatively predictable positions, and the lack of variation makes several scenes feel rather repetitive. It doesn't do enough to maintain the momentum or give the film the visual energy it desperately needs.
The production itself also looks noticeably cheap at times. It's clear that the filmmakers had to work with a limited budget, and the relatively small number of locations reflects that. There's nothing inherently wrong with making a contained drama on a modest budget, but the problem is that the limitations are often too visible.
Part of this comes down to the cinematography and lighting, which don't always manage to create a convincing atmosphere. The sets are another issue. Several environments simply don't feel particularly realistic, occasionally making it difficult to believe that the characters are actually inhabiting the world the film is trying to portray.
For a movie set in such an oppressive historical environment, the production design should do a lot of the heavy lifting. Sadly, it doesn't always succeed.
A Slow Pace Makes It Difficult to Stay Engaged
Another significant issue is the pacing. At 132 minutes, Confession is not exactly a short film, and unfortunately, it doesn't always have enough interesting material to justify its running time. There are stretches where very little happens, and the story struggles to maintain a consistent sense of progression.
The film is heavily dialogue-driven, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Some of the conversations are genuinely interesting, and there is a certain depth to the discussions about morality, faith, guilt and human nature. The underlying themes give the screenplay more substance than your average historical drama.
However, having meaningful conversations doesn't automatically make them entertaining to watch. Too often, scenes go on longer than necessary without adding enough new information or emotional weight to keep things engaging.
In fact, Confession frequently feels more like watching a stage play than an actual movie. The limited locations, static camera work and lengthy dialogue exchanges all contribute to that impression. There is certainly a theatrical quality to the way the story unfolds, but the filmmakers don't always manage to translate that approach into something particularly cinematic.
Confession Handles Its Mystery Better Than Its Suspense
Where Confession does deserve some credit is in the way it handles its central mystery. There is enough uncertainty surrounding the characters, their motivations and the events that brought them to this point to make the story reasonably intriguing. The screenplay does a decent job of gradually revealing information and giving the audience reasons to question what they are seeing.
Unfortunately, the same cannot be said about the suspense. Despite the oppressive setting and the nature of the interrogation, the film rarely manages to create the kind of tension you would expect from a psychological drama about imprisonment under Stalin's regime.
Part of the problem is that the film doesn't always give you enough reason to care about its characters. Their conversations might be intellectually interesting, but there isn't always a strong emotional connection. As a result, the stakes don't feel quite as significant as they should, and several potentially powerful moments fail to have the desired impact.
This is particularly disappointing because the premise offers plenty of opportunities for genuinely tense and uncomfortable scenes. Instead, the film often settles for lengthy exchanges that are interesting in theory but less effective in practice.
Final Verdict: Is Confession (2026) Worth Watching?
Ultimately, Confession is a film with some interesting ideas and a surprisingly strong cast, but it never quite manages to bring all its elements together. James Franco and Rob Lowe provide some worthwhile performances, while Nick Nolte also has moments that make an impression. The underlying mystery and the deeper themes surrounding faith, morality and personal convictions give the story a certain amount of substance.
However, the static cinematography, cheap-looking production design, unconvincing performances from some of the extras and, above all, the slow pacing make it difficult to remain consistently engaged. The film also struggles to generate genuine suspense or establish a strong emotional connection with its characters.
There is a decent psychological drama somewhere within Confession, and the cast certainly deserves credit for trying to bring it to life. Unfortunately, too much of the film feels like watching a stage production rather than experiencing a fully realised cinematic story.
It's not without its merits, and there are enough interesting moments to make it worth a look for fans of dialogue-driven historical dramas. Just don't expect a particularly gripping or visually impressive experience.
Rating: 6/10
